Hi everyone, my name is Sofia, I am a new member of weall. I am from Portugal.
I have just read that SoftBank is investing a lot of money in France for AI data centres. I am personally very worried about this. AI seems to me like a complete waste of resources and energy, the epitome of the society we have built in “the west”, completely disconnected from reality and nature.
I was wondering what people think about this? And if you have any ideas on how we can stop these sorts of projects? Why is Europe trying to enter this “AI race”, which leads to nowhere good?
1 Like
A warm welcome to this space, Sofia! And yes - I share your concerns around AI and that innovation is not necessarily the same as progress even though the two are often used interchangeably. Hope to see you around as part of our members’ calls!
1 Like
Tagging @AamirahWEAll2 too in this thread- there are a few members interested in chatting about AI- perhaps worth linking up with them to have a deeper conversation on this?
1 Like
First, I would like to know what you mean when you say ai. Do you mean llms, machine learning, a combination, or something else?
In any case, my thoughts are complex. I see ai generally as a tool. Whether it is a hammer, a gun, or a nuke is dependent on the above definition, who uses it, and for what purpose. All three answer why the politicians and economic elites continue to pursue it despite the danger. Two parts fear, one part hope.
There are a few ways i can see to stop it. To be clear these are likely not the only options, just the ones my imagination can come up with.
- Forceful deconstruction. Either by the community or by convincing the on site workers to join your cause. Construction workers are a rough bunch though and many of us are just trying to eat. That leads to my next option. Which is slower and possibly more work, and probably less likely to produce results before it can be built.
- A person who can feed themselves cannot be extorted for labor, a person who can do so comfortably will attract their neighbors, a neighborhood that can feed themselves and others have leverage to move the levers of power.
- Combine the 2. Make the choice easier for the workers by providing a community for them if they agree to walk away. Not a union, a community. Preferably of people who can provide their own needs and create enough surplus to share while living a comfortable and dignified life.
I know those are pretty generic options and they aren’t as helpful to your specific situation as I’d like, but they’re what I have for now. I’m all about saying “how can we” instead of “we can’t” though so if you wanna talk more about it I’m happy to discuss.
Defining terms matters here — when I hear “AI” in these debates it usually turns out to mean large language models, not the broader machine learning picture, and the two have very different footprints. Your point about who benefits sticks with me too; the rush behind data centres seems driven as much by positioning as by usefulness. I’m less convinced by the deconstruction route, since the people building these facilities are earning a living like anyone else. The community angle is the part worth developing.
Defining terms first is the right instinct, and I’d add that even within LLMs the footprint splits between training and inference, which changes the argument about siting. On the who-benefits point, the positioning angle seems to explain the pace better than actual demand does, at least from what’s publicly reported. I share your skepticism about deconstruction, not least because the workers are the easiest people to blame and the least able to absorb the cost. The community idea is where I’d want to dig in: what would that look like in practice, and who would hold the surplus?
On the training versus inference split, that distinction seems underused in local arguments here in Atlanta, where the grid questions get lumped together as one “data centre” problem. The inference side is what keeps drawing power long after the headlines fade, and that changes how siting should be debated. As for the surplus question, the honest answer is I don’t know who should hold it. A community that pools resources usually does so through some structure, and structures tend to reproduce the same power imbalances people were trying to escape. Who keeps the books matters as much as who builds the barn.
Appreciate the response. I understand where you’re coming from. The people working there need to eat too. So do the people working in factories to build fidget spinners, the people on oil rigs, and the people building guns and bombs. Every time I hear this argument (especially in the last decade) it feels like “our convenience is more important than your grandkids ability to feed themselves.”
Just because something is providing jobs doesn’t make it good or a worthwhile expenditure of our limited resources. The latest climate and soil reports show that the cup is overflowing. Our grandchildren cannot afford for us to keep building for convenience over need. People building and working in these pointless or actively harmful industries have skills that transfer to something that can halt or reverse harm.
If you’re interested in learning about self sustaining community that use structures to prevent those power imbalances do a deep dive into the Haudenosaunee Confederacy (and remember that a lot of what was written about them was written by colonial Europeans who thought they were “sophisticated barbarians” so take that stuff with a huge grain of salt) and the Inuits for some of the most resiliant from history and the Foundation for Intentional Community for the thousands people trying to build them now.
If you wanna help develop one that can scale and replicate check out my post here:
The surplus goes to the community individuals needs first, then goes towards a replication stack that can be used to create a new community (or rebuild yours in a disaster). Once replication hits an equilibrium surplus goes to community individuals convenience first, then from then on the surplus you create is yours to give away. It’s a tiny bit more complex than that but thats the general gist of a relational economy.
Currently I’m working on adding a tool for creating the trust network. I thought it was common knowledge that you needed one for this type of system but was wrong. My current thinking is a coming of age ceremony where young adults are given the opportunity and encouraged to travel to several other communities over a couple years and try to develop at least one close tie in each community. This allows for cultural exchange as well as the ability to find someone you know and trust who knows and trusts whoever you might work with. Of course that is just one example of one social technology that can fulfill that role, and it needs to be paired with a physical supply chain, which can be handled by slow moving solar-electric vehicles in a caravan style system. Any thoughts?